Duck Fails — A&E, Duck Dynasty and the First Amendment

It’s been a while since we’ve had a pop culture fake First Amendment incident. More than two years have passed since ESPN dropped Hank Williams Jr. from the Monday Night Football opening after Hank got all rowdy and compared Pres. Obama to Hitler.

Why must you live out those songs that you wrote, Hank?

The latest celebrity to be booted off the air for saying something controversial off the air is Phil Robertson of A&E hit “Duck Dynasty,” which follows a family in Louisiana who makes duck calls. In an interview with GQ, Mr. Robertson, an avowed Bible-reading Christian, stated, among other things, that homosexuality is sinful and on par with bestiality and prostitution. A&E suspended Mr. Robertson. Then the First Amendment “defenders” came out.

Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal issued this statement:

“Phil Robertson and his family are great citizens of the State of Louisiana. The politically correct crowd is tolerant of all viewpoints, except those they disagree with. I don’t agree with quite a bit of stuff I read in magazine interviews or see on TV. In fact, come to think of it, I find a good bit of it offensive. But I also acknowledge that this is a free country and everyone is entitled to express their views. In fact, I remember when TV networks believed in the First Amendment. It is a messed up situation when Miley Cyrus gets a laugh, and Phil Robertson gets suspended.”

Other characters have joined Gov. Jindal in his support of Mr. Robertson, including a half-term half-witted former politician who had her own reality shows and will not be linked on this blog. They suggest that because we have a First Amendment, that Mr. Robertson should be allowed on the air to say whatever he wants. I’m all in favor of First Amendment protections and free speech but I have to admit that there is no First Amendment issue here. The First Amendment prevents the government and government actors from restricting expression. In this situation, it isn’t the FCC or any government branch that is suspending Mr. Robertson, but his broadcaster, A&E, by itself. The First Amendment does not usually apply to private relationships such as the one between A&E and its TV personalities (and ESPN and Hank Williams Jr.). There’s probably even a provision in their contracts that allows such as suspension or cancellation. The First Amendment creates no right to be on TV. I’m not surprised that Gov. Jindal is mixed up over the First Amendment because he has had some struggles with it in the past.

Mr. Robertson’s views might upset people but are far from unique. A great many politicians and clergymen say similar things and are allowed on TV, especially on news and political shows. A&E could have let him stay on the air and even give him an entire show of him ranting on whatever he wants. But would advertisers, viewers and cable subscribers like that? That’s probably what motivated A&E.

I base my decisions on business.

While we’re on the First Amendment, it should be noted that it also grants a right of free association and its inverse of dissociation. A&E is free to not associate with Mr. Robertson or his co-stars provided it satisfies any legal obligations it might have.

Chris DeMatteo is an attorney and the sole member of DeMatteo Legal Solutions at 2911 Dixwell Ave., Ste. B10, Hamden, CT. Call (203) 691-6594 or visit the office website. Attorney DeMatteo represents clients in criminal, juvenile and civil matters in all of Connecticut's courts.

166 thoughts on “Duck Fails — A&E, Duck Dynasty and the First Amendment”

  1. Pingback: this contact form
  2. Pingback: luxury
  3. Pingback: Pure Leverage
  4. Pingback: money making blog
  5. Pingback: Kleding Sale
  6. Pingback: OIfEKOGkd9
  7. Pingback: veggenti viventi
  8. Pingback: Miracle Rooter
  9. Pingback: yoga poses
  10. Pingback: EJaCLZmxSl
  11. Pingback: 5KZscpgt4q
  12. Pingback: kooora
  13. Pingback: jSfKowUVZH
  14. Pingback: bp51vcdHyV
  15. Pingback: q9s60v8nD8
  16. Pingback: IfDuyKlrzG
  17. Pingback: seo outsourcing
  18. Pingback: bcHGc6SoQZ
  19. Pingback: talks about it
  20. Pingback: ed pills
  21. Pingback: mluhfjbgdbnmjmlfs
  22. Pingback: Gabriel Parco
  23. Pingback: fitflop usa
  24. Pingback: karen millen sale
  25. Pingback: iPhone Unlock
  26. Pingback: vbgjhtkulifsdkjhtn
  27. Pingback: script software
  28. Pingback: natural erection
  29. Pingback: visit the site
  30. Pingback: Miami escorts
  31. Pingback: bistroMD
  32. Pingback: Secret
  33. Pingback: dropshippers
  34. Pingback: balterio sklep
  35. Pingback: design templates
  36. Pingback: top
  37. Pingback: lamisil mentax
  38. Pingback: erection remedies
  39. Pingback: buffalo web design
  40. Pingback: herbs impotence
  41. Pingback: methotrexate ddi
  42. Pingback: depilacja laserowa
  43. Pingback: narozniki
  44. Pingback: soundcloud promos
  45. Pingback: temovate skin
  46. Pingback: lunatik promo code
  47. Pingback: herbs impotence
  48. Pingback: lunatik promo code
  49. Pingback: Herpes Cure
  50. Pingback: vimax
  51. Pingback: can ed be cured
  52. Pingback: payday loans
  53. Pingback: lidocaine science
  54. Pingback: krav maga warszawa
  55. Pingback: paznokcie
  56. Pingback: angielski paszport
  57. Pingback: nowa szyba skoda
  58. Pingback: szczesliwy zwiazek
  59. Pingback: agencje eventowe
  60. Pingback: artykuly religijne
  61. Pingback: e cigaret batteri
  62. Pingback: hosting
  63. Pingback: Computers
  64. Pingback: viagra sklep
  65. Pingback: schody na beton
  66. Pingback: Education
  67. Pingback: allhamptonbay.com
  68. Pingback: meble biale
  69. Pingback: HERCULEANEAW.INFO
  70. Pingback: www.mykunci.com
  71. Pingback: iherb coupon code
  72. Pingback: niacinamide
  73. Pingback: rule31mediators.us
  74. Pingback: Sexual Problem
  75. Pingback: projekty przylacza
  76. Pingback: czasy angielskie
  77. Pingback: Niacin
  78. Pingback: reklama Gliwice
  79. Pingback: dsvoip.us
  80. Pingback: portal turystyczny

Comments are closed.