Dzokhar Tsarnaev Informed of His Rights…Our Rights.

Following the capture of Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzokhar Tsarnaev, many media members and armchair attorneys beat ourselves up over whether Mr. Tsarnaev would and should be given his Miranda rights by the investigators and prosecutors before they attempted to question him. The “public safety” exception that was articulated in New York v. Quarles, 467 U.S. 649 (1984), was cited as authority to question him before he was given his Miranda rights and still use those statements against him at trial.

Some quick background on Miranda. As I wrote in my Sound of Silence post last week, the Miranda rule, rooted in the right against self-incrimination, requires law enforcement authorities to advise a suspect in custody that he or she has the rights to remain silent and to consult with an attorney before questioning. The Miranda warning does not have to be given at the time of arrest (as it is for nearly every TV arrest) but only before the suspect is questioned. The remedy for a violation is that the statements obtained absent the confession cannot be used at trial against the defendant. Very often the government can prove a defendant’s guilt without a confession. Ernesto Miranda for one, had his original conviction overturned in the case that led to the rule which now bears his name, but was convicted again in his second trial without his confession in evidence. (After he was released from prison, Miranda made some money autographing Miranda rights cards.) Whether he was advised of his rights or not, these are rights that Mr. Tsarnaev always had. These are rights that we all have in our criminal justice system.

Once counsel attaches, a defendant cannot be questioned without the consent of his or her lawyer.

Mr. Tsarnaev was advised of his rights by a federal judge in his initial appearance, which was held yesterday in the hospital where he is being treated for his injuries. The right to counsel attaches at this hearing and the court appointed a federal (public) defender to represent Mr. Tsarnaev in that and subsequent proceedings. Since he is represented by counsel, he cannot be questioned by investigators or prosecutors without his attorney’s knowledge and presence. This right is based in the Sixth Amendment (incorporated on the states by the 14th) right to counsel. All persons charged with a crime have the right to effective counsel. Now that he is charged with various crimes, Mr. Tsarnaev has will be afforded such representation. The court advised him of this right as well as his Fifth amendment right against self-incrimination. Read the transcript of that hearing below:

Transcript of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev's bedside hearing

If you followed me on Twitter the past few days (if you don’t follow me, do so here), you’d see that I was in the camp to inform Mr. Tsarnaev of his rights before any questioning. I am skeptical of any expansion of existing exceptions to rights and protections because these are all of our rights.

We’re done here.

Chris DeMatteo is an attorney and the sole member of DeMatteo Legal Solutions at 2911 Dixwell Ave., Ste. B10, Hamden, CT. Call (203) 691-6594 or visit the office website. Attorney DeMatteo represents clients in criminal, juvenile and civil matters in all of Connecticut's courts.

142 thoughts on “Dzokhar Tsarnaev Informed of His Rights…Our Rights.”

  1. Pingback: trainer
  2. Pingback: Check This Out
  3. Pingback: limited tort
  4. Pingback: no jailbreak hacks
  5. Pingback: urlman 9990mine
  6. Pingback: honorbound gold
  7. Pingback: Unlock iPhone
  8. Pingback: Joaquina Amin
  9. Pingback: fitflop slippers
  10. Pingback: web space hosting
  11. Pingback: pv solar companies
  12. Pingback: free seo software
  13. Pingback: filmy online
  14. Pingback: elocon patient uk
  15. Pingback: we-vibe
  16. Pingback: diet meal delivery
  17. Pingback: Free
  18. Pingback: dropshippers
  19. Pingback: erection remedies
  20. Pingback: oxsoralen ul
  21. Pingback: buffalo web design
  22. Pingback: personal loans
  23. Pingback: dump methotrexate
  24. Pingback:
  25. Pingback: sukienki ciazowe
  26. Pingback: buy plays
  27. Pingback: Cure for herpes
  28. Pingback: lunatik promo code
  29. Pingback: valtrex appearance
  30. Pingback: cleaners
  31. Pingback: lidocaine diseases
  32. Pingback: vimax porn
  33. Pingback: herbs impotence
  34. Pingback: can ed be reversed
  35. Pingback: xylocaine overcast
  36. Pingback: lidocaine in kcl
  37. Pingback: penis size
  38. Pingback: paznokcie
  39. Pingback: tutaj
  40. Pingback: akcesoria kuchenne
  41. Pingback: artykuly reklamowe
  42. Pingback: agencje eventowe
  43. Pingback: din e cig
  44. Pingback: enlarge penis size
  45. Pingback: iherb coupon
  46. Pingback: iherb coupons
  47. Pingback: Pets
  48. Pingback: cialis
  49. Pingback: meble drewniane
  50. Pingback: schody na beton
  51. Pingback: Health
  52. Pingback: Idealia
  53. Pingback: coupon
  54. Pingback: iherb coupon code
  55. Pingback:
  56. Pingback: czasy angielskie

Comments are closed.