What’s the Deal With Plea Bargaining?

My favorite episode of Perry Mason is the one in which Perry reaches a deal with the DA and his client takes it instead of going to trial. A close second is the time Perry requests a continuance because he has to be in another court.

“Your honor, may we have a few more weeks so my client can consider Mr. Burger’s offer?”

The reality is that few criminal cases ever go to trial. Many are resolved through diversionary programs (such as AR) or nolles. The bulk of criminal cases are resolved through guilty pleas. As we know, a criminal defendant is innocent until proven guilty. After a defendant his arraigned, he enters an initial plea, which is usually “not guilty,” and the case proceeds. The plea is a decision that only a client can make. At some point, barring a program or a nolle, the State will extend an offer for a guilty plea: if the defendant changes his or her plea to guilty (or nolo contendere or Alford pleas), the State will recommend a certain punishment and/or will drop or lower some of the charges. The court might even weigh in with what it will sentence the defendant should he plead out. If the defendant rejects the offer, the case could be set down for trial. An agreement can still be reached at any time but we’re dealing with the basic contract principles of offer and acceptance. The State is under no obligation to extend a new offer or to accept a defendant’s counter-offer (back to contracts class, a counter-offer is a rejection). The defendant can plead guilty anyway and leave the sentence up to the court without an offer from the State–this is an open plea–but it is only for the charges before him. Once the court finds probable cause for an offense, the defendant can be brought to trial for it. Only the State decides what to charge a defendant with.

What can a defendant do if he or she does not like the State or court’s offer? Take the case to trial. If only it were that easy. Although that decision is solely the client’s, a criminal defense attorney must advise him or her in that decision and make a recommendation. A poor recommendation to try a case or plead out may constitute ineffective assistance. I enjoy trying cases but my clients’ decisions aren’t about my fun. Their lives and liberty are at stake, as well as the people they support and depend on. For someone who is sitting in jail unable to bond out, the prospect of getting hammered after a loss at trial is often not worth the risk when a plea for lesser charges can get him out much faster. This happens a lot in drug cases wherein the statutes expose a defendant to lengthy prison terms. Other times preconfinement credit and split sentences can free someone almost immediately as long as he pleads to something. Sometimes the punishment isn’t the time but the offense–becoming a felon and suffering all of the ensuing collateral consequences.

Do we have five suspended after two with three years probation?

All of the scenarios, charges, evidence and consequences are what we talk about with clients, sometimes in the courthouse lockup. I never like telling a client to stop fighting; to give up his rights and go to jail. What I like less is when a client makes a poor decision. So much of this work isn’t staying out of jail but getting out of jail.

Chris DeMatteo is an attorney and the sole member of DeMatteo Legal Solutions at 2911 Dixwell Ave., Ste. B10, Hamden, CT. Call (203) 691-6594 or visit the office website. Attorney DeMatteo represents clients in criminal, juvenile and civil matters in all of Connecticut's courts.

143 thoughts on “What’s the Deal With Plea Bargaining?”

  1. Pingback: Click here
  2. Pingback: Pure Leverage
  3. Pingback: chiropractor
  4. Pingback: DMA Portland BBB
  5. Pingback: MAKING MONEY BLOG
  6. Pingback: t boned
  7. Pingback: click to watch
  8. Pingback: ed pills
  9. Pingback: Unlock iPhone
  10. Pingback: Lon Schumer
  11. Pingback: cloud web hosting
  12. Pingback: Trackback
  13. Pingback: www.gtavcc.com
  14. Pingback: Trackback
  15. Pingback: breaking bad xbox
  16. Pingback: Trackback
  17. Pingback: hit counter
  18. Pingback: google pagerank
  19. Pingback: Trackback
  20. Pingback: laptop notebook
  21. Pingback: Trackback
  22. Pingback: Erotica
  23. Pingback: bistro diet review
  24. Pingback: Miami City Girls
  25. Pingback: buffalo web design
  26. Pingback: herbs impotence
  27. Pingback: kanapy
  28. Pingback: erection remedies
  29. Pingback: lunatik promo code
  30. Pingback: Trackback
  31. Pingback: lunatik promo code
  32. Pingback: Cure for herpes
  33. Pingback: foods for ed
  34. Pingback: Trackback
  35. Pingback: tutaj
  36. Pingback: angielski paszport
  37. Pingback: tester
  38. Pingback: nowa szyba volvo
  39. Pingback: cigaretter pris
  40. Pingback: nostatic
  41. Pingback: iherb coupon code
  42. Pingback: fast cash loans
  43. Pingback: Photography
  44. Pingback: viagra online
  45. Pingback: MLM
  46. Pingback: stopnie schodowe
  48. Pingback: Health
  50. Pingback: www.mykunci.com
  51. Pingback: niacinamide review
  52. Pingback: rule31mediators.us
  53. Pingback: niacinamide
  54. Pingback: Buty
  55. Pingback: projekty co
  56. Pingback: Niacin
  57. Pingback: portal turystyczny
  58. Pingback: reklama Gliwice

Comments are closed.